So there’s this thing. A term of art that apparently everyone (who’s anyone) knows what it means and its relative import (very) in the scheme of things. There’s even a mediocre-to-bad movie I cannot bring myself to watch.
When did this become a thing? How did this become a thing? It wasn’t a thing when I was growing up. It wasn’t a thing when I was a young adult.
So when did Bucket List become a thing?
According to June Thomas at Slate.com,
In 2004, the term was used—perhaps for the first time?—in the context of things to do before one kicks the bucket (a phrase in use since at least 1785) in the book Unfair & Unbalanced: The Lunatic Magniloquence of Henry E. Panky, by Patrick M. Carlisle. That work includes the sentences, “So, anyway, a Great Man, in his querulous twilight years, who doesn’t want to go gently into that blacky black night. He wants to cut loose, dance on the razor’s edge, pry the lid off his bucket list!”
Interesting enough. But right now, even though a Google search has helped me to establish the likely origins of the phrase and given me more insight into its place in the Zeitgeist, mostly what I want to say is
Fuck the Bucket List
Yes, the concept sappily pulls at our heart strings — the not-so-great movie is about two older men breaking out of a cancer ward in order to, before they die, do things have never done before. I mean, who is going to be a Grinch about that?
Enter me, stage now.
There are several web sites that are vehicles to help any one of us to create a bucket list — from our own ideas, or inspired by items on other people’s list — and then to track our progress. As one of these web sites promises, you can “achieve your life goals.”
A bucket list of EXPERIENCES is better than the accumulation of THINGS. It does have that going for it.
PROBLEM #1: Yet there is still the whole aspect of intrinsic materialism here — let’s turn life into goals that can be measured and achieved (and likely, lots of money spent and planet resources consumed “on the journey”).
Though most of us (at least those who are sighted) can see a sunset without much financial cost, I am pretty darn sure it costs beaucoup buckaroos for most of us to see the Northern Lights (or swim with dolphins or “see Egypt” or what have you).
PROBLEM #2: Another pet peeve I have with this bucket-list-sh*t: its focus on the future. It’s wicked hard to stay in the now if you are trying to check off the next item on your list.
PROBLEM #3: the striving for more. The seduction of status-seeking: cool items to check off the list and competitively comparing progress (“How many do you have left? I’ve already done __________”). There’s a Tumblr that is actually called “the perfect bucket list.” Yes, in case you didn’t know, perfection is possible. And if your list is not like this one, made of contributions from folks around the globe, well, then, yours is flawed.
PROBLEM # 4: One more thing to add to my crank list. Bucketlist.org asks,
As if most people who are compelled to create such a list are just lazing about, passive, unknowing, and just need a little kick start from a web site. There’s a built-in judgment that life is not fully lived until one a) creates a bucket list and b) checks off most or all of the items on it.
For instance, the thing that might have you “waiting” could be a cancerous tumor ravaging your body from the inside out, swelling your right arm and fingers, chemotherapy having burnt itself out, malignant rash extending further and further.
Maybe, just maybe, you are “waiting” for a miracle — which is otherwise, in this case, called a moment — without debilitating pain, to get out of the recliner that has been moved into the room with the best sunlight and playful shadows dancing on the walls. Maybe while you are waiting, you have the salve of companionable friends telling terrible jokes and laughing nonetheless because they love you and sometimes laughter is better than tears (though not always).
Maybe, the waiting is not actually waiting, but is choosing to be with what is here now, even if that is grief. Grief at what is already lost, what is being lost, what will go undone, interspersed moments of appreciation for what was and what is.
In the movie (and book, for all I know), “Wild (2014),” there is this line:
There is a sunrise and a sunset every day and you can choose to be there for it. You can put yourself in the way of beauty.
At the risk of being too trite, I think there is something wise and true here. Certainly something wiser than any bucket list. So here’s my advice:
Don’t go chasing the list.
Fuck the bucket.
Instead, put yourself in the way of beauty.
10 thoughts on “F*ck Bucket Lists”
I don’t mind the idea of curating a fine collection of “wouldn’t it be cool ifs” and maybe even doing some of them – but people actually seriously use this as a competitive ticky-box race-to-the-win kind of thing? Ye gods and small fishes.
That’s awful. It misses the point entirely.
(Sometimes I have similar feelings about other long processes with lots of complicated nested steps. The impulse to ticky-box through such things is strong… but it’s not the done but the doing…)
I like that: it’s not the done but the doing…
Somehow I have never bothered to have one. I think planning ahead is ok so you don’t spin your wheels. But tomorrow is my bucket list. I am in the process of writing a song that says that people spend too much energy on things like bucket lists; worrying if the glass is too big and waiting for their ship to come in.
sometimes chasing tomorrow is easier than living today, but ultimately it’s an echo, not the real thing.
Love, love, love this. I have had similar feelings but didn’t know why until you articulated them. Thanks!
So glad, Tina, to hear this. I posted your post from last week on my FB page and got alot of people saying, “hell yeah.” So right backatcha!
Amen, Sister! I wrote similarly on this topic a couple years ago: http://lakechalice.blogspot.com/2013/07/kick-bucket-list.html You’ve expressed beautifully what I was trying to say.
Thanks for stopping by, Meredith! I enjoyed your piece on the same subject.
The whole idea of the bucket list, to me, is to stop and think about the things you wish you were paying attention to or doing that you’re not, and if they’re really important to you, to pay attention to or do them. Guess I’m not being competitive or perfectionistic enough!
So some of the things I’ve written on such lists for myself are: Become a parent, Fly a kite, See the Grand Canyon (did ’em, can die now); Go to Año Nuevo when the elephant seals are therem Grow some veggies in our yard (not yet); Walk another half-marathon (screw it). And yes, I want to see the Northern Lights. Trite but true.
It’s all about the why. If it points you toward beauty and meaning, great. If not, drop it. Thanks for the perspective.
I love your painting.
Thanks for stopping by, Amy. Yes: beauty.